jatiN mahindrA doT coM

Two recent articles sparked some discussion around the question if SEOs that specialize in an industry or two are more qualified then SEOs that do not specialize. One article was from Search Engine Land and the other from Top Rank Blog.

Lee Odden said:

Experience in a particular industry may be important on one level, but a company that specializes in a particular vertical warrants questions about conflict of interest. How can a company specialize in “real estate” for example, without working for competing firms? The biggest advantages that come industry specific experience is the ability to quickly ramp up on client key messaging and audience needs as well as connections made online for content promotion, online public relations and link building.

To me, there is nothing better then having an SEO that is 100% devoted to your site and has been an SEO in your industry for a couple years. These SEOs have the experience of seeing, day in and day out, what has been working on your site and your competitors. But if you can’t afford to hire a full time SEO, then hiring a company is a good alternative. Should that company have direct experience in the industry that you are in? You can see the pros and cons to that. Direct experience means they have other clients that are your competitors but yet they know what it takes to rank you well.

So let me ask you, should SEOs specialize in a specific industry or not? This really applies to all work categories, from lawyers to web developers to doctors and caterers, but still, let’s poll you guys:

Forum discussion at Sphinn.

Related posts:

1. Google Ditches Local Listings for SEOs and Designers
2. Google Back Tracks a Bit on Dropping SEOs & Webmasters from Local Results
3. Google Removes SEOs from Local One Pack in Search Results
4. SEOs Freak Out: Google To Personalize All Search Results
5. Survey: Most SEOs Won’t Link To Competitors
6. Google Adds More Search Options & Cleans Up Verticals
7. Why the UK SEO industry doesn’t have an image problem
8. Google Certified SEOs = Top Contributors / Bionic Posters?
9. 80% Of SEOs Said They Can Beat Wikipedia In Google
10. SEOs Excited For Google Analytics API
11. 80% Say SEOs Need Some Coding Abilities
12. SEO’s Split on Importance of Specialization in Industry Sectors